Opposing Counsel

Does Opposing Counsel Usually Go to Trial? How to Find Out

Quick answer

You can find out whether opposing counsel usually goes to trial by reviewing how their past cases of the same type ended in public court records. Count how many ended in an order after a contested hearing versus a consent order or voluntary dismissal, and check the dockets for trial settings. The result shows their usual pattern, not what will happen in your case.

Key takeaways

  • In family court, a trial is usually a hearing before a judge, not a jury.
  • Orders after contested hearings and consent orders usually read differently, which helps you sort them.
  • A simple tally of similar cases shows whether a lawyer usually settles or usually goes to a hearing.
  • Knowing the pattern helps you plan time, costs and preparation.
  • The other party's choices matter as much as their lawyer's habits.

"We'll see you in court." Maybe the other side's lawyer said it. Maybe you're just wondering whether your case will end in a hearing or an agreement. Either way, it's a fair question, and one that changes how you plan your time, your money and your preparation.

No one can tell you for sure how your case will end. But you can find out how this lawyer's past cases usually ended, and that's a meaningful clue. This guide explains what "trial" means in North Carolina family court and a step-by-step method for checking a lawyer's history in public court records.

What counts as "going to trial" in family court?

In family court, going to trial usually means a contested hearing where a judge hears evidence and decides the disputed issues. Family matters in North Carolina are generally heard in District Court and decided by a judge, so the courtroom looks different from the jury trials on television.

It also helps to separate hearings by type:

  • Temporary hearings set short-term arrangements while the case is pending, such as a temporary custody schedule or temporary support.
  • Motion hearings address specific requests, such as information disputes or enforcement.
  • Final hearings (often what people mean by "trial") decide issues like permanent custody, child support or equitable distribution.

A lawyer might go to many temporary hearings and still settle most cases before a final hearing. When you review their history, track these separately. For a general walk-through of the courtroom itself, see what happens at a family court hearing in North Carolina.

How to find out whether opposing counsel usually goes to trial

The way to find out is to review how the lawyer's past cases of the same type ended, using public court records. Here's a practical method:

  1. Build a case list. Search North Carolina public court records for recent cases where the lawyer appeared. Many records are searchable online; some require a request to the Clerk of Superior Court.
  2. Filter to cases like yours. Same case type (for example, custody), and ideally the same county.
  3. Read each docket. Look for final hearing or trial settings and whether those settings went forward or were continued. Our guide on how to read a court docket explains the entries.
  4. Read the final order. Orders after contested hearings usually describe the hearing and the evidence presented. Consent orders usually state that the parties agreed.
  5. Sort each case into one of four buckets: contested final hearing, consent order, voluntary dismissal or still open.
  6. Tally the results and note how long each case took.

A simple tally you can build yourself

A simple tally of similar cases makes a lawyer's pattern visible at a glance. Here's a hypothetical example of what a finished tally might look like for a fictional lawyer, Attorney D, across recent custody cases:

Case endingCount (hypothetical)Notes
Order after contested final hearing3Each had at least one continuance first
Consent order7Four were entered within a week of a hearing date
Voluntary dismissal1Filed shortly after mediation
Still open2Not counted in the pattern

In this made-up example, Attorney D usually settles, often late, and goes to a full hearing in a minority of cases. Someone facing Attorney D might prepare fully for a hearing while also expecting a settlement proposal close to the date. For more on reading that kind of timing, see what opposing counsel's settlement history tells you.

Signals in the docket worth noting

Beyond the final outcome, some docket entries give extra context:

  • Trial or final hearing dates that were set more than once.
  • Pretrial orders or exchanges of exhibit and witness lists.
  • Mediation entries followed by a quick consent order.
  • Orders that resolve some issues by agreement and leave others for the judge.

Why it matters whether opposing counsel goes to trial

It matters because a case headed for a contested hearing asks different things of you than a case headed for an agreement. Knowing the likely path helps you plan:

  • Time: Contested cases often take longer, with more court dates and time off work.
  • Cost: If you have a lawyer, a full hearing usually means more preparation hours.
  • Preparation: Witnesses, exhibits and practice testimony all take time to arrange.
  • Negotiation: If late settlements are common, you can plan time to review an offer calmly.

Questions to bring to your own lawyer

If you have an attorney, a trial tally gives you concrete questions to raise instead of a vague worry. For example:

  • This lawyer's similar cases usually ended by consent order. Should we expect a proposal, and when?
  • Their final hearings were often continued at least once. How should I plan time off work?
  • Their contested cases took longer than most. What does a realistic timeline look like for us?
  • Which witnesses and documents would we need if this does go to a full hearing?

If you're representing yourself, the same questions help you build your own calendar and checklist. The point isn't to guess the ending. It's to make sure neither ending catches you unprepared.

What a trial history can't tell you

A lawyer's trial history can't tell you what the other party wants, what your judge will decide or how your specific facts will play out. Clients decide whether to settle, so even a lawyer who usually settles may go to a full hearing if their client insists. And a small number of cases can make a pattern look stronger than it is. Treat the tally as a tendency, not a forecast.

An Opposing Counsel Report Card does this sorting for you across 12 or 24 months of North Carolina cases, with each case summarized and a contested results grade that only counts cases that were actually fought.

Preparing for either path

The safest plan is to prepare as though your case will go to a full hearing, while staying open to an agreement if one makes sense for you. Knowing whether this lawyer usually goes to trial helps you set realistic expectations about timing and effort, so you're ready either way. Keep your documents organized, keep your communication calm and written, and talk with a licensed North Carolina attorney about decisions that affect your case.

Frequently asked questions

Are family law trials in North Carolina in front of a jury?

Family matters in North Carolina are generally heard in District Court and decided by a judge. That's why people often talk about a custody or property hearing rather than a jury trial.

Is a temporary hearing the same as a trial?

No. A temporary hearing addresses short-term arrangements while the case is pending. The final hearing decides the issues for the longer term. When you review a lawyer's history, it helps to track the two separately.

Why would a lawyer who usually settles take my case to trial?

Because clients decide whether to settle. If the other party won't agree, or the dispute is genuine, a lawyer who usually settles may still go to a full hearing. History shows tendencies, not rules.

This article is general information about researching attorneys and North Carolina court records. It is not legal advice, and Firmbinder LLC is not a law firm. For advice about your situation, talk to a licensed North Carolina attorney.