NC Court Records

Attorney Report Card Grading: How Each Grade Is Calculated

Quick answer

An Attorney Report Card gives four letter grades from public North Carolina court records: Experience and volume (how many cases over how many years), Contested results (a smoothed score of wins, losses and splits in cases that were actually fought), Speed to resolution (median case time compared with a reference time for that matter type) and Procedural reliability (concerns such as withdrawals or sanctions per reviewed case). The overall grade is the average of the graded categories on a 4.0 scale, and any grade without enough cases is left blank.

Key takeaways

  • Every grade comes with its rule, so you can see exactly why an attorney received it.
  • Contested results count only cases that were actually fought, using a smoothed score that keeps small samples from looking extreme.
  • Speed is the median of each case's time divided by a reference time for that matter type.
  • Reliability counts concerns per reviewed case; a single concern in a large caseload still matters, but less.
  • A grade is left blank when there are too few cases to grade fairly, and the overall average skips blank grades.

A letter grade is only useful if you know what earned it. A "B" with no explanation is just someone's opinion. A "B" with a published rule, built from public court records, is something you can understand, question and compare.

That's how an Attorney Report Card works. Every grade comes with the rule behind it, every rule uses public North Carolina court records, and any grade without enough data is left blank. This article lays out the full grading method, with hypothetical examples, so you know exactly what you're reading.

How is an attorney report card graded?

An Attorney Report Card is graded in four categories plus an overall grade, using cases found in public North Carolina court records, mainly the statewide eCourts portal and the documents filed in each case. The four categories are Experience and volume, Contested results, Speed to resolution and Procedural reliability. Each one has a fixed rule and a minimum number of cases. If the minimum isn't met, the grade is left blank. We say so instead of guessing.

The four grades at a glance

CategoryWhat it measuresMinimum to grade
Experience and volumeHow many cases, over how many years5 cases
Contested resultsWins, losses and splits in cases that were actually fought3 contested cases
Speed to resolutionCase time compared with a reference time for that matter type3 closed cases
Procedural reliabilityWithdrawals, sanctions or contempt, documented procedural problems3 reviewed cases

Experience and volume

The experience grade measures how many cases we find for the attorney and over how many years. The thresholds are:

  • A: 75 or more cases over 5 or more years
  • B: 40 or more cases over 3 or more years
  • C: 15 or more cases
  • D: 5 or more cases
  • Not graded: fewer than 5 cases

There is no F. Volume says how much work is on the record, not whether it was good. A newer attorney with a D may still be a strong fit, which is why the other grades and the case summaries matter.

Contested results

The contested results grade measures outcomes only in cases that were actually fought. Uncontested paperwork, such as a simple agreed order, is never counted as a win. The score is smoothed:

(wins + ½ × splits + 2) ÷ (contested cases + 4)

Smoothing adds two "imaginary" wins and two "imaginary" losses to every record. That pulls small samples toward 50%, so an attorney with two lucky results doesn't look better than one with a long, solid record. The thresholds are: A at 70% or higher, B at 60% or higher, C at 50% or higher, D at 40% or higher, and F below 40%. At least 3 contested cases are required.

Here are hypothetical examples:

Hypothetical attorneyContested recordSmoothed scoreGrade
Attorney A4 contested: 4 wins(4 + 2) ÷ 8 = 75%A
Attorney B4 contested: 3 wins, 1 loss(3 + 2) ÷ 8 = 62.5%B
Attorney C20 contested: 15 wins, 5 losses(15 + 2) ÷ 24 = 70.8%A
Attorney D12 contested: 5 wins, 2 splits, 5 losses(5 + 1 + 2) ÷ 16 = 50%C
Attorney E2 contestedNot enough casesBlank

Notice that Attorney B's raw record is 75%, but smoothing brings it to 62.5% because four cases is a small sample. For why raw win rates mislead, see attorney win rates explained.

Speed to resolution

The speed grade compares how long each closed case took with a reference time for that type of matter. For each case, we divide the days from filing to disposition by the reference days, then take the median across cases. The median is the middle value, so one unusually long case doesn't distort the grade.

Suppose, purely for illustration, a matter type had a reference time of 100 days. A case that closed in 80 days scores 80%. The thresholds are: A at 75% or less, B at 100% or less, C at 125% or less, D at 150% or less, and F above 150%. At least 3 closed cases are required. In a hypothetical record with case scores of 60%, 80%, 95%, 110% and 140%, the median is 95%, which earns a B.

Faster isn't always better for every client. Our article on why speed to resolution matters covers the trade-offs.

Procedural reliability

The reliability grade counts concerns per reviewed case. Concerns include withdrawals before the case ended, sanctions or contempt against the client's side, and documented procedural problems. The thresholds are: A at zero concerns, B at 0.10 or fewer per case, C at 0.20 or fewer, D at 0.35 or fewer, and F above 0.35. At least 3 reviewed cases are required.

In hypothetical terms: 20 reviewed cases with 1 concern is 0.05 per case, a B. Ten reviewed cases with 3 concerns is 0.30, a D. Each concern is tied to the specific case that shows it, so you can read the context yourself.

The overall grade

The overall grade is the average of the graded categories on a 4.0 scale, where A is 4, B is 3, C is 2, D is 1 and F is 0. Blank categories are skipped, not counted as zero. A hypothetical attorney with A, B, B and C averages 3.0. If no category can be graded, the overall is left blank too.

What the grades don't measure

Grades come from court records, so they can't measure communication, responsiveness, fees or how a lawyer treats clients. They also can't see confidential cases or private settlements. Our article on what court records can't tell you about a lawyer covers these limits, and every report includes a confidence note about what its records do and don't cover.

Grades with their work shown

A report card is only as honest as its method. Fixed rules, minimum case counts, smoothing for small samples, medians instead of averages for speed, and blank grades where data is thin all serve one goal: grades you can trust and check. You can see every rule in action in our sample report for a fictional attorney, and read more about our sources on How It Works.

When you're ready to look at a real attorney, a Hiring Report Card covers 12 or 24 months of cases, with every grade, case summary and pattern tied to the records behind it. It's general information to help you make an informed choice, not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

Why is there no F for experience?

Experience measures how much work we can find, not whether that work was good or bad. An attorney with fewer than 5 cases isn't failing; there simply isn't enough record to grade, so the grade is left blank.

Does a high contested results grade mean the attorney will win my case?

No. Grades describe what happened in past public cases. Every case has different facts, judges and parties, and no record can predict a result. The grades help you ask better questions and make an informed choice.

How do you decide what counts as a win?

Only cases that were actually fought count, and uncontested paperwork is never counted as a win. Each case summary in the report shows what was asked for and how it ended, so you can check the classification yourself. Our How It Works page describes the method.

Are plain-English explanations included with the grades?

Yes. Each grade appears with the rule used to compute it, and the report adds case-by-case summaries, patterns tied to specific cases, and a confidence note about what the records do and don't cover.

This article is general information about researching attorneys and North Carolina court records. It is not legal advice, and Firmbinder LLC is not a law firm. For advice about your situation, talk to a licensed North Carolina attorney.