Opposing Counsel

How Experienced Lawyers Scout the Other Side's Attorney

Quick answer

Experienced lawyers scout the other side's attorney by combining what they already know from prior cases and colleagues with structured research: checking the State Bar directory and specialist status, reviewing the attorney's dockets and filings in similar cases, watching them in public hearings and reviewing transcripts or recordings where lawfully available. The results usually go into a short scouting memo covering background, case history, habits and preparation notes.

Key takeaways

  • Scouting mixes informal knowledge with structured research in public records.
  • A scouting memo usually covers background, case history, habits and preparation notes.
  • The depth of scouting varies widely with a lawyer's network, time and the client's budget.
  • Newer lawyers and out-of-county lawyers often have the least informal knowledge to draw on.
  • Outside research can fill gaps, but every finding should be checked against the source records.

Before a significant hearing, many experienced lawyers want to know who's on the other side, not just the opposing party but the opposing attorney. How do they usually open? Do they settle late? Do they object constantly or rarely? Will they push for fees?

Scouting opposing counsel is a long-standing part of trial preparation, though it's rarely taught formally. This article describes how experienced lawyers typically do it, what a scouting memo covers and why the quality of scouting varies so much. It's written for attorneys and paralegals, and for clients who want to understand what their lawyer may already be doing.

How do experienced lawyers scout opposing counsel?

Experienced lawyers scout opposing counsel by combining informal knowledge, such as prior cases against the attorney and conversations with colleagues, with structured research in public sources like the State Bar directory, court dockets, filings and hearings. The balance depends on how well they already know the attorney and how much is at stake.

The traditional scouting toolkit

The traditional toolkit has six main parts. Most lawyers use some mix of them rather than all six every time.

1. Prior dealings

The fastest source is memory. A lawyer who has faced the same attorney before knows their style firsthand. The limit is that memory is selective, and one case may not represent how the attorney usually operates.

2. Colleague conversations

Lawyers often ask colleagues about an opposing attorney's general reputation and courtroom style. This can be valuable, but it's secondhand and uneven, and it depends heavily on who you know.

3. State Bar and specialist check

The North Carolina State Bar's online member directory confirms license status and admission details, and the State Bar also makes public discipline available. The Board of Legal Specialization's list shows whether the attorney is a board certified specialist.

4. Docket and filing review

Reviewing the opposing attorney's dockets and filings in similar cases shows pace, motion habits, requested relief and how cases ended. Many North Carolina records are searchable online through the statewide eCourts case portal; some require a request to the Clerk of Superior Court. See how to read opposing counsel's past filings for a reading worksheet.

5. Courtroom observation

Watching the attorney in a public hearing shows tone, pacing and how they handle the bench. It's time-consuming and depends on timing.

6. Transcripts and recordings

Where prior hearings were recorded and recordings or transcripts are lawfully available, they show the attorney's actual questioning and argument. Our article on how lawyers use prior hearings to prepare covers this in detail.

What a scouting memo usually covers

A scouting memo is a short internal summary of what's known about the opposing attorney, organized so the trial lawyer can read it quickly. A typical structure:

  1. Background: license status, years in practice, specialist certification, any public discipline.
  2. Case history: recent cases of the same type, which side they represented, judges and outcomes.
  3. Pace: how long their cases usually take and how often hearings are continued.
  4. Resolution style: share of cases settled versus decided after contested hearings, and timing of settlements.
  5. Motion and relief habits: recurring motions, fee requests and proposed order language.
  6. Courtroom notes: opening style, questioning habits, objection frequency, reaction to pushback, where known.
  7. Reliability flags: withdrawals, sanctions or documented procedural problems, with case references.
  8. Preparation notes: what to expect and what to have ready.

Why scouting is so uneven

Scouting quality varies widely because it depends on resources that vary widely. The main factors:

FactorWhy it matters
NetworkLawyers with long local careers have more informal knowledge to draw on
GeographyAn attorney from another county may be unknown to local colleagues
TimeDocket and filing review across many cases takes hours
Client budgetClients pay for research time, so scouting is often trimmed
Record accessSome records require a clerk request, which adds delay
Recall biasMemorable cases can crowd out typical ones

The result is that two lawyers preparing for the same opponent may walk in with very different pictures of them. A newer lawyer, or one practicing outside their usual county, often has the thinnest picture of all.

Guardrails that keep scouting appropriate

Good scouting stays inside clear boundaries. Experienced lawyers and their staff generally keep to a few guardrails:

  • Public sources only. State Bar records, public dockets and filings, open courtrooms and lawfully available recordings.
  • No sealed or confidential material. Juvenile matters, sealed documents and confidential proceedings stay out of it.
  • No contact with represented parties from the attorney's other cases, and no attempts to learn confidential information from former clients.
  • Courtroom rules respected. Observation follows each courtroom's rules on phones and recording.
  • Facts kept separate from rumor. Colleague impressions are labeled as impressions, not mixed in with record findings.
  • Verification before reliance. Any finding that will shape preparation is checked against the source document.

These boundaries protect the client, the lawyer and the people involved in other cases, and they make the resulting memo more trustworthy.

Building scouting in-house versus using outside research

Firms handle this in different ways. Some assign docket and filing review to a paralegal and have the trial lawyer review a summary. Others rely mainly on experience and colleague input. A growing option is outside research that does the record review and delivers a structured summary for the lawyer to verify and use. Our article on why opposing counsel research can save billable hours looks at the time trade-off.

An Opposing Counsel Report Card covers the attorney's North Carolina cases over 12 or 24 months, with case summaries, graded categories that show the rule behind each grade, recurring tactics tied to specific cases and a confidence note on what the records do and don't cover. The attorney is not notified. Whatever the source, findings should be checked against the underlying records before they shape preparation.

Scouting as ordinary preparation

Scouting the other side's attorney isn't about gamesmanship. It's ordinary preparation, the same instinct that leads a lawyer to read the judge's prior orders or review the local rules. Done well, it replaces impressions with evidence and helps the lawyer and client know what to expect. Done unevenly, it leaves gaps that can surface at the worst moment. A structured, source-based approach, whether built in-house or brought in from outside, narrows those gaps.

Frequently asked questions

Is it ethical for lawyers to research opposing counsel?

Researching public information about the opposing attorney, such as license status, public discipline and public court filings, is a normal part of preparation. Lawyers still have to follow their professional conduct rules, including rules about communicating with represented parties.

Do paralegals usually handle opposing counsel research?

In many firms, paralegals or junior lawyers pull dockets and filings while the supervising lawyer reviews the findings and decides how to use them. Practices vary by firm size and case.

How long does a thorough opposing counsel review take?

It depends on the attorney's caseload and how easy the records are to reach. Reviewing dockets and filings across many cases can take hours or days, which is why many lawyers limit scouting to the most similar recent cases.

This article is general information about researching attorneys and North Carolina court records. It is not legal advice, and Firmbinder LLC is not a law firm. For advice about your situation, talk to a licensed North Carolina attorney.