How to Communicate with Opposing Counsel: Rules and Templates
If you have a lawyer, communication with opposing counsel generally goes through your lawyer, because professional conduct rules generally bar a lawyer from discussing the case directly with a person they know is represented. If you're representing yourself, opposing counsel may contact you directly, but they represent the other side and should not give you legal advice. Either way, keep communication in writing, brief, factual and polite, and assume anything you send could be shown to a judge.
Key takeaways
- If you have a lawyer, let your lawyer handle communication with opposing counsel.
- If you're self-represented, opposing counsel may contact you, but they work for the other side.
- Write every message as if a judge will read it, because one might.
- Short, factual, one-topic emails are easier to track and harder to misread.
- Follow up any phone call or hallway conversation with a brief written summary.
When the other side has a lawyer, every message you send feels like it carries extra weight. It does. Emails can be printed, attached to motions and handed to a judge. A rushed reply at midnight can follow you into the courtroom.
The good news is that communicating with opposing counsel well isn't complicated. It comes down to a few clear rules about who talks to whom, a consistent style and some simple templates. This guide covers all three.
Should you communicate with opposing counsel directly?
It depends on whether you have a lawyer. If you do, communication with opposing counsel should generally go through your lawyer. If you're representing yourself, opposing counsel will usually communicate with you directly.
If you have a lawyer
Lawyers' professional conduct rules generally bar a lawyer from discussing a case directly with a person they know is represented, unless that person's lawyer agrees. So if you have an attorney, opposing counsel should contact your attorney, not you. If they reach out to you anyway, politely say you have a lawyer, give your lawyer's name and tell your lawyer about the contact.
If you're representing yourself
Opposing counsel may contact you directly by letter, email or phone. They represent the other party only. They should not give you legal advice, other than suggesting you get your own lawyer, and they're not neutral, even when they're friendly. For more on going without a lawyer, see representing yourself against an attorney in North Carolina.
Ground rules for communicating with opposing counsel
The safest ground rule is to write every message as if a judge will read it, because one might. From there, a few habits make communication clearer and less risky:
| Do | Don't |
|---|---|
| Use email or letters so there's a record | Rely on phone calls without a written follow-up |
| Keep each message to one topic | Bundle five issues into one long email |
| State facts with dates | Use labels like "liar" or "always" and "never" |
| Ask for proposals in writing | Agree to terms in a hallway conversation |
| Take a day before replying to anything upsetting | Reply the moment you feel angry |
| Keep copies of everything, sent and received | Delete messages, even unpleasant ones |
| Be polite, even when they aren't | Match a sharp tone with a sharper one |
What not to share
Opposing counsel is not your confidant. Avoid sharing:
- Your plans for the hearing, or what you think your weak points are.
- What your own lawyer told you, if you have one.
- Your feelings about the other party.
- Private details beyond what the communication actually requires.
Short email templates you can adapt
Short, neutral templates help you respond consistently without getting pulled into an argument. Adapt the bracketed parts. These are communication templates, not legal advice about what to say on any issue.
Acknowledging a letter or email
I received your [letter/email] dated [date]. I am reviewing it and will respond by [date].
Asking for a document or clarification
Your [date] email refers to [document]. Please send me a copy so I can review it. Thank you.
Responding to a scheduling request
I am available on [dates]. I am not available on [dates] because of [work/other court date]. Please confirm the date once it is set with the court.
Moving a phone conversation to writing
Thank you for your call today. I prefer to handle case matters by email so we both have a clear record. Please send your proposal in writing and I will review it.
Summarizing a phone call
To confirm our call on [date]: you said [point]. I said I would [action] by [date]. If I have misunderstood anything, please let me know in writing.
Phone calls and courthouse hallway conversations
Phone calls and hallway conversations are where self-represented people most often agree to things they later regret. Opposing counsel may approach you before a hearing with a proposal. That's normal, and sometimes it leads to a reasonable agreement. But it's also high pressure. A few general points:
- You can listen without agreeing.
- You can ask for the proposal in writing and time to read it.
- You can tell the judge, if a hearing is about to start, that you were given a proposal and need time to review it. Ask the clerk's office how that's usually handled.
- Write down what was said as soon as the conversation ends.
How you carry yourself in these moments matters too. See courtroom demeanor: what opposing lawyers notice.
Keeping a simple communication log
A communication log is a running, dated list of every exchange with opposing counsel. It takes a few minutes per entry and saves hours of searching later, especially if a dispute comes up about who said what and when. For each exchange, record:
- The date and time.
- How it happened: email, letter, phone call or in person.
- A one-line summary of what they said or asked.
- A one-line summary of how you responded.
- Any date or deadline mentioned, and whether it came from a court order or just from the message.
- Where the original is saved.
Keep the log with your printed or saved copies, in date order. If you have a lawyer, share it with them. If you don't, it becomes a quick reference when you're preparing for a hearing and need to show what was communicated.
Knowing the lawyer's communication style in advance
Lawyers have communication habits, just as they have filing habits. Some send formal letters with firm warnings in nearly every case. Others prefer short emails and phone calls. Some send settlement proposals early; others send them the week of a hearing. Knowing which you're dealing with helps you read each message in context. Our guide to handling intimidating letters from opposing counsel explains how to separate tone from substance.
An Opposing Counsel Report Card describes an attorney's recurring tactics in their North Carolina cases, along with an opposing lens on what to expect from them.
Every message is part of the record
The simplest way to communicate with opposing counsel is to treat every message as something a judge might read: short, factual, polite and focused on one topic. If you have a lawyer, let them do the talking. If you don't, use writing, keep copies, follow up calls with emails and take time before replying to anything upsetting. These habits don't require legal training, and they help keep the focus where it belongs: on the facts of your case.
Frequently asked questions
Can opposing counsel call me if I have a lawyer?
Generally, no. Lawyers' professional conduct rules generally bar them from discussing the matter directly with someone they know has a lawyer, unless that lawyer agrees. If the other side's lawyer contacts you, politely refer them to your attorney and let your attorney know.
Should I talk to opposing counsel on the phone?
Many self-represented people prefer email because it creates a clear record. If you do talk by phone, take notes and send a short email afterward summarizing what was discussed and anything agreed.
Can I send opposing counsel my evidence before the hearing?
Whether and when you must share documents with the other side depends on the rules for your type of case and any court orders. Ask a licensed attorney or the clerk's office about procedure before deciding what to send.
Is it okay to communicate with my ex instead of their lawyer?
Parents often still need to communicate about day-to-day parenting. Keep those messages focused on the child's logistics and follow any court order about contact. For case issues, it's common to communicate through the lawyer, and you can ask a licensed attorney what's appropriate.
This article is general information about researching attorneys and North Carolina court records. It is not legal advice, and Firmbinder LLC is not a law firm. For advice about your situation, talk to a licensed North Carolina attorney.