NC Court Records

Attorney Sanctions and Contempt: What They Signal About a Lawyer

Quick answer

Attorney sanctions are penalties a judge imposes for improper conduct in a case, such as filings without a proper basis or ignoring discovery rules, and they can fall on the lawyer, the client or both. Contempt is a finding that someone willfully disobeyed a court order, and in family cases it usually involves a party, not the lawyer. Neither is the same as State Bar discipline. A sanction against the lawyer personally is more significant than contempt against a client.

Key takeaways

  • Sanctions punish improper litigation conduct; contempt addresses disobeying a court order.
  • A sanction aimed at the lawyer personally says more about the lawyer than one aimed at the client.
  • Contempt in family cases usually reflects a party's conduct, such as missed support payments.
  • A motion for sanctions or contempt is only a request; look for the order that granted or denied it.
  • State Bar discipline is a separate system; check it separately.

Few phrases in a court record sound as alarming as "sanctions" and "contempt." If you see them in the case history of a lawyer you're considering, it's natural to wonder whether you should walk away.

Sometimes they are a real warning sign. Often they're not about the lawyer at all. The difference depends on who the penalty was aimed at, why, and whether it shows up once or as a pattern. This guide explains what attorney sanctions and contempt mean, how they differ from State Bar discipline, and how to read them fairly.

What are attorney sanctions?

Attorney sanctions are penalties a judge imposes for improper conduct in a lawsuit. Common reasons include filing papers without a proper legal or factual basis, filing for an improper purpose such as harassment or delay, failing to follow discovery rules, or ignoring court rules and deadlines. A sanction can be aimed at the lawyer, the client or both.

Sanctions take different forms, such as:

  • Ordering payment of the other side's attorney fees caused by the conduct
  • Striking a filing or limiting what evidence a party can use
  • Other measures the court finds appropriate in that situation

What is contempt of court?

Contempt of court is a finding that someone willfully disobeyed a court order or disrupted the court. In family cases, contempt most often involves a party, not a lawyer: a parent who doesn't pay court-ordered support, doesn't follow a custody schedule or doesn't transfer property as ordered.

Civil vs. criminal contempt

Civil contempt is generally aimed at making someone comply with an order going forward, and the person can often end it by complying. Criminal contempt is generally aimed at punishing past conduct. The record and the order will usually say which type was involved.

Sanctions, contempt and State Bar discipline compared

Sanctions, contempt and State Bar discipline are three separate systems. Here's how they differ:

Court sanctionsContemptState Bar discipline
Who imposes itThe judge in the caseThe judge in the caseThe North Carolina State Bar's disciplinary process
Usually aimed atThe lawyer, the client or bothUsually a partyThe lawyer
Typical reasonImproper filings or litigation conductDisobeying a court orderViolating professional conduct rules
Where to find itThe case fileThe case fileState Bar public discipline records

To check the last column, see our guide on how to check if a lawyer has been disciplined in North Carolina.

What sanctions and contempt signal about a lawyer

What a sanction or contempt finding signals depends on three questions: who it was aimed at, why, and how often it happens.

Who was it aimed at?

A sanction imposed on the lawyer personally is the most significant, because it reflects the lawyer's own conduct. A sanction on the client may reflect the client's choices, the lawyer's advice, or both, and the order may say which. Contempt against a client usually reflects the client's behavior outside the courtroom.

Why was it imposed?

Read the order. A sanction for a missed deadline is different from a sanction for a filing the judge found had no proper basis. Contempt for a single late payment during a job loss is different from repeated refusal to follow a custody order.

How often does it happen?

One sanction in a long career may be a bad day or an unusual case. Repeated sanctions across a lawyer's cases are a pattern worth taking seriously. Repeated contempt findings against many of a lawyer's clients may simply reflect the kinds of cases they take, but it's fair to ask how they counsel clients about following orders.

Motions vs. orders: don't confuse a request with a finding

A motion for sanctions or a motion for contempt is only a request, and many are denied. Some lawyers file these motions often as a tactic. When you see one in a record, follow it through the case history:

  1. Find the motion and note who filed it and against whom.
  2. Look for a hearing date or a show cause order.
  3. Find the order that resolved it: granted, denied, withdrawn or dismissed.
  4. If granted, read what the court found and what it ordered.

A lawyer who often files sanctions or contempt motions against the other side is showing you a tactic, not misconduct. That's useful information too, especially if they're likely to be on the other side of your case someday. Our article on opposing counsel motion habits covers how to read those patterns.

Where to look in the case history

Sanctions and contempt rarely appear as a single tidy entry. Look for a motion, then a notice of hearing or an order to appear, then a hearing entry, and finally an order. Sometimes the result is folded into a broader order that also addresses custody, support or fees, so read the whole order rather than skimming for the word "sanctions."

Questions to ask before you hire

If you find sanctions or contempt in a lawyer's cases, ask about them calmly. Lawyers who have been practicing for a while expect informed clients. Useful questions include:

  • "I saw a sanctions order in one of your cases. Can you tell me what happened, in general terms?"
  • "How do you make sure filings and deadlines are handled correctly?"
  • "How do you advise clients about following temporary orders?"

Watch the response as much as the answer. A calm, clear explanation is a good sign.

How sanctions and contempt appear in a Report Card

In a Hiring Report Card, sanctions or contempt against the client's side count toward the procedural reliability grade, along with withdrawals before the case ended and documented procedural problems. Each concern is tied to the specific case that shows it, so you can read the context yourself. For how withdrawals factor in, see what a motion to withdraw as counsel signals.

Read the order before you judge the lawyer

Sanctions and contempt can be meaningful signals, but only after you know who they were aimed at, why they happened and how often they appear. A personal sanction against the lawyer is a serious matter; contempt against a struggling client usually isn't about the lawyer at all; and a motion that was denied is just a request.

Read the orders, check the State Bar separately, look for patterns rather than single events, and bring your questions to the consultation. That approach keeps a scary-sounding word from making the decision for you.

Frequently asked questions

Is being sanctioned the same as being disciplined by the State Bar?

No. A court sanction is a penalty imposed by a judge in a specific case. State Bar discipline is a separate process that addresses a lawyer's professional conduct and can affect their license. A lawyer can be sanctioned in a case without any State Bar action, and the reverse is also possible.

If a lawyer's client was held in contempt, is the lawyer at fault?

Usually not directly. Contempt in family cases most often involves a party failing to follow an order, such as missing support payments or not following a custody schedule. The lawyer's role is to represent the client, not to control their behavior. A repeated pattern across many clients is still worth a question.

Can I see sanctions orders in public court records?

In public cases, sanctions orders and contempt orders are generally part of the court file. You can often find them through the case history on the eCourts portal or request copies from the Clerk of Superior Court in the county where the case was filed.

This article is general information about researching attorneys and North Carolina court records. It is not legal advice, and Firmbinder LLC is not a law firm. For advice about your situation, talk to a licensed North Carolina attorney.