How to Give Your Lawyer Better Intel on the Other Side's Attorney
To give your lawyer better information about the other side's attorney, collect verifiable public facts, such as license status, public discipline, recent cases with outcomes and repeated habits like continuances or fee requests, and organize them in a one-page brief with a source for every item. Leave out rumors, don't contact the other attorney or anyone from their past cases, and let your lawyer decide what's relevant.
Key takeaways
- Your lawyer can use organized, sourced facts far more easily than opinions or rumors.
- A one-page brief with a source for every item saves your lawyer time.
- Public sources include the NC State Bar directory and public court records.
- Never contact the other attorney, their clients or parties from their past cases.
- Your lawyer decides what's relevant; your job is to make the facts easy to check.
You know things about your case that your lawyer doesn't. You may also be able to find things about the other side's attorney that your lawyer hasn't had time to look up. The challenge is handing that information over in a way your lawyer can actually use.
A long, emotional email full of guesses rarely helps. A short, organized brief with a source for every fact often does. This guide explains what kind of information about opposing counsel is useful, how to gather it from public sources, how to organize it and what to avoid. It ends with notes for attorneys and paralegals on using client-provided research.
What kind of information about opposing counsel helps your lawyer?
The information that helps your lawyer most is organized, verifiable and sourced: facts they can check quickly against public records. Opinions, rumors and secondhand stories are much harder to use, because your lawyer can't rely on them without confirming them first.
Compare these two ways of saying the same thing:
- Hard to use: "Everyone says this lawyer drags cases out forever."
- Easy to use: "In six recent custody cases, the final hearing was continued at least once in five. Case list attached."
The second version gives your lawyer something specific to verify and think about.
What your lawyer may already know, and what they may not
Your lawyer may already know the other attorney's general reputation, especially if they practice in the same county. What they may not have is a systematic review of the other attorney's recent cases, because that takes time, and time costs you money. Our article on how experienced lawyers scout the other side's attorney describes what lawyers typically do on their own.
Your research is most valuable when it fills that gap: recent, specific, sourced and focused on cases like yours.
What to collect from public sources
The most useful items come from two public sources: the North Carolina State Bar and North Carolina public court records. Here's a checklist:
- License status and admission details from the State Bar's online member directory.
- Any public discipline made available by the State Bar.
- Board certified specialist status from the State Bar's Board of Legal Specialization.
- Recent cases of the same type as yours, with the county, which side they represented and how each ended. Many records are searchable online; some require a request to the Clerk of Superior Court.
- Repeated habits visible in the dockets, such as continuances, early temporary motions, fee requests or late consent orders.
- Your own case's history with this attorney: every letter, email and filing, in date order.
Our step-by-step guide to researching opposing counsel explains how to find each item.
How to organize it: a one-page brief
A one-page brief is the easiest format for a busy lawyer to read. Use the same structure every time:
| Section | What to include |
|---|---|
| 1. Who | Attorney's name, firm name as listed, license status, specialist status, any public discipline |
| 2. Cases reviewed | How many cases, which case types, which counties, what time period |
| 3. Outcomes | How those cases ended: consent orders, dismissals, orders after contested hearings |
| 4. Habits | Two to five repeated patterns, each with the cases that show it |
| 5. In our case | A dated list of this attorney's communications and filings in your case |
| 6. Questions | Things you noticed but don't understand |
| 7. Sources | Where each fact came from, so your lawyer can verify it |
Put the case list on a separate page as an attachment. Keep the brief itself to one page. If you're not sure what a pattern is versus a one-off, see what a lawyer's pattern of practice is.
When and how to hand it over
The best time to hand over research on opposing counsel is early, well before a hearing, so your lawyer has time to check it and decide what matters. A few practical points:
- Ask first. Ask your lawyer whether background on the other attorney would be useful and how they'd like to receive it: email, printed pages or a shared folder.
- Send it once, then update. Send the brief as a single document, then send short updates only when something new happens, such as a new filing or a new letter.
- Bring it to a meeting. If you have a scheduled meeting, bring a printed copy and point to the two or three items you think matter most.
- Keep the timing realistic. Research sent the night before a hearing is hard for anyone to use well.
- Keep the original sources. Save the dockets and documents you relied on in case your lawyer asks to see them.
Handled this way, your research arrives as a tool, not a distraction, and your lawyer can fit it into their own preparation.
What not to do
Some kinds of "research" can hurt your case or hurt other people. Avoid all of these:
- Don't contact the other attorney about anything beyond what your own lawyer has approved.
- Don't contact the attorney's clients, former clients or parties from their other cases.
- Don't look into the attorney's personal life. Stick to their professional record.
- Don't post about them online, including reviews or comments in groups.
- Don't try to access sealed or confidential records.
- Don't record in courtrooms or anywhere recording isn't allowed.
- Don't tell your lawyer what to do with it. Offer it as background; let them decide.
Notes for attorneys and paralegals
If a client hands you research on opposing counsel, a few practices help you use it well:
- Verify before relying. Spot-check a few cases against the source records.
- Separate facts from impressions. Treat any client opinions as context, not findings.
- Look for gaps. Clients often miss cases in other counties or cases where the attorney appeared under a different firm name.
- Consider structured outside research. When time is short or the caseload is large, an Opposing Counsel Report Card covers the attorney's North Carolina cases over 12 or 24 months, with case summaries, graded categories showing the rule behind each grade and patterns tied to specific cases.
- Set expectations with the client about what the research will and won't change in your approach.
Making the facts easy to use
You don't need legal training to give your lawyer useful information about the other side's attorney. You need public sources, a little patience and a consistent format. Collect verifiable facts, organize them on one page, cite where each came from and leave the decisions to your lawyer. Done that way, your research becomes something your lawyer can check in minutes and build on, which helps both of you walk into the next hearing knowing what to expect.
Frequently asked questions
Will my lawyer be offended if I research opposing counsel?
Most lawyers appreciate organized, accurate information, especially when it saves time. It helps to frame it as background for them to check and use as they see fit, not as instructions.
Does my lawyer already know the other attorney?
Sometimes. Lawyers who practice in the same area and county often know each other's reputations. Even so, a structured review of recent cases can add detail that memory and reputation don't capture.
Will giving my lawyer research reduce my legal bill?
It may save some research time, but that depends on your lawyer and your fee agreement. Ask your lawyer whether organized background on the other attorney would be useful and how they'd like to receive it.
This article is general information about researching attorneys and North Carolina court records. It is not legal advice, and Firmbinder LLC is not a law firm. For advice about your situation, talk to a licensed North Carolina attorney.