What's Inside an Opposing Counsel Report Card
An Opposing Counsel Report Card is a research report on the attorney representing the other side, built from North Carolina public court records over 12 or 24 months. It includes the cases we can find where the attorney appeared, four letter grades plus an overall grade (each with the rule used to compute it), case-by-case summaries, patterns tied to specific cases, a hiring lens, an opposing lens with preparation steps and a confidence note on what the records cover.
Key takeaways
- The report covers the attorney's North Carolina cases over a 12-month or 24-month window.
- Four graded categories plus an overall grade, each showing the rule used, and blank when there are too few cases.
- Every pattern in the report is tied to the specific cases that show it.
- The opposing lens describes what to expect and practical preparation steps.
- The attorney is never contacted or notified, and the report is general information, not legal advice.
If the other side in your case has a lawyer, you've probably wondered what that lawyer is like. Do they usually settle? Do their cases drag on? Do they ask for fees? You could spend days in court records trying to answer those questions, or you could read a structured summary of what the records show.
That's what an Opposing Counsel Report Card is. This article walks through each section, explains how the grades work, covers the 12-month and 24-month options and is clear about what the report doesn't do.
What is an Opposing Counsel Report Card?
An Opposing Counsel Report Card is a research report on the attorney representing the other side of your case, built from North Carolina public court records, mainly the statewide eCourts case portal and the documents filed in each case. It covers a lookback window of 12 or 24 months.
It's designed for people who want to know what to expect from the other side's lawyer and prepare accordingly, whether they're self-represented or working with their own attorney. It's also confidential: we never contact the attorney or the other party, and the attorney is not notified.
What's in the report, section by section
The report has seven main sections, moving from raw case data to grades, patterns and practical lenses.
1. The case list
Every case we can find where the attorney appeared in the lookback window, with the case type, which side they represented, the judge and how the case ended.
2. Four grades plus an overall grade
Each grade comes with the rule used to compute it, so you can see exactly why the attorney received it.
| Grade | What it measures |
|---|---|
| Experience & volume | How many cases the attorney handled, over how many years |
| Contested results | Wins, losses and splits in cases that were actually fought; uncontested paperwork isn't counted as a "win" |
| Speed to resolution | How long their cases take compared with a reference time for that type of case |
| Procedural reliability | Withdrawals before the case ended, sanctions or contempt against their client's side, and documented procedural problems |
| Overall | A single overall grade, also shown with the rule used to compute it |
A grade is left blank when there are too few cases to grade fairly. We say so instead of guessing. For the detail behind each rule, see how an attorney report card is graded.
3. Case-by-case summaries
For each case: what was asked for, what happened and how it ended, including money awarded such as child support, alimony or attorney fees.
4. Patterns
Strengths, concerns and recurring tactics, each tied to the specific cases that show it. If the report says an attorney often files early temporary custody motions, it points to the cases where that happened.
5. The opposing lens
What to expect from this attorney, and practical preparation steps based on their record. If you're facing this attorney, this is the section that turns the record into preparation.
6. The hiring lens
Who this attorney fits well or poorly, what to expect and questions to ask before hiring. It's included in every report and gives you another angle on how the attorney works.
7. The confidence note
What the records do and don't cover for this attorney, including any areas where too few cases were found to draw a fair conclusion.
12 months or 24 months?
The Opposing Counsel Report Card comes in two lookback windows:
- 12 months, $500. A focused look at the attorney's most recent year of cases. A reasonable fit when the attorney is active and you mainly want their current habits.
- 24 months, $1,000. Two years of cases. More cases usually means more categories can be graded fairly and patterns are clearer, which matters when the attorney's caseload is lighter or more spread out.
If you're unsure which you need, the pricing page compares them side by side, and the sample report shows a complete Report Card for a fictional attorney.
Ways to put the report to use
The report is most useful when you turn it into concrete preparation. A few practical ways to use it:
- Read the cases most like yours first. Same case type, ideally the same county or judge, are the most relevant summaries.
- Turn the opposing lens into a checklist. If the report notes early temporary motions or late settlement proposals, plan your calendar and documents around those possibilities.
- Check the money. Case summaries show amounts awarded, including attorney fees, which helps you understand what this attorney usually asks for.
- Share it with your attorney. If you have a lawyer, the report gives them an organized starting point with case references they can verify.
- Write down your questions. Patterns you don't understand are good questions for a licensed attorney consultation.
What the report doesn't do
An Opposing Counsel Report Card is general information, and it's worth being clear about its limits:
- It isn't legal advice, and it doesn't tell you what to file, argue or agree to.
- It doesn't predict how your case or your judge will decide.
- It doesn't include sealed, juvenile or confidential matters.
- It can't show private negotiations, client instructions or confidential mediation.
- It doesn't involve contacting anyone. The attorney and the other party aren't contacted.
Our article on what court records can't tell you about a lawyer explains these limits in more depth. You can also read how it works for our method and data sources.
When Battle Research is the better fit
If you have a hearing coming up against this attorney and want to understand how they operate in the courtroom itself, Battle Research goes further. The Battle Pass ($2,500) includes the 24-month Opposing Counsel Report Card plus audio of up to 3 of the attorney's prior public hearings, obtained only from public proceedings and only where lawfully available, converted to speaker-labeled transcripts and analyzed for patterns such as how they open, how they question witnesses and self-represented parties, their objection habits and how they respond when a judge pushes back. DEEP Analysis ($3,900) covers up to 8 hearings, prioritizes hearings before the same judge and of the same type, and adds a question-by-question cross-examination breakdown and a deep read of their filed motions and proposed orders in similar cases. See Battle Research vs. Report Card to compare. Whichever you choose, the goal is the same: to know what to expect, prepare calmly and ask better questions of your own attorney.
Frequently asked questions
How much does an Opposing Counsel Report Card cost?
The 12-month Opposing Counsel Report Card is $500, and the 24-month version is $1,000. Battle Research, which adds hearing audio analysis, starts at $2,500.
Will the attorney know I ordered a report on them?
No. North Carolina Attorney Report never contacts the attorney or the other party, and the attorney is not notified.
Can I see an example before ordering?
Yes. A full sample Report Card for a fictional attorney is available on the sample report page, so you can see every section before you order.
Does the report tell me what to file or argue?
No. The report is general information drawn from public court records. It helps you know what to expect and ask better questions, but it isn't legal advice. Talk with a licensed attorney about decisions in your case.
This article is general information about researching attorneys and North Carolina court records. It is not legal advice, and Firmbinder LLC is not a law firm. For advice about your situation, talk to a licensed North Carolina attorney.